Orange Cyberdefense is calling on organisations to determine in advance who may isolate or shut down systems during a cyberattack. According to the company, the board should define those powers in what it calls a ‘pull-the-plug mandate’. The Dutch regional water authority Hoogheemraadschap van Rijnland already works with such a mandate.
In its call, Orange Cyberdefense refers to recent hacks of refrigeration systems. According to the company, shutting down such installations can lead to spoiled food, financial losses and empty supermarket shelves. In other environments, switching off a system can affect water treatment, production processes or emergency services. Security specialists must then weigh up whether to intervene immediately to limit further damage, or to keep systems running at the risk of an attacker spreading further.
Orange Cyberdefense argues that this decision requires technical expertise as well as an understanding of the consequences for the organisation and its surroundings. The company therefore believes that responsibility should not rest solely with the IT department. The board should decide in advance who may intervene and within what limits.
A practical example at Rijnland
During a webinar hosted by Orange Cyberdefense, Hoogheemraadschap van Rijnland and Veiligheidsregio Utrecht, the Dutch safety region responsible for emergency services in the Utrecht area, explained how both organisations handle this responsibility within critical infrastructure. At Rijnland, a pull-the-plug mandate forms part of the approach. CIO Sierk Hoeksma explained that the mandate sets out who may isolate or shut down systems during a cyber incident, under what circumstances this is permitted and which interests take priority. The board agrees these arrangements in advance, so that no debate about authority arises during an incident.
Four conditions
Orange Cyberdefense identifies four matters that organisations should address in a pull-the-plug mandate.
The first is that the board determines which risks are acceptable. According to Hoeksma, the board must set out frameworks covering which processes must keep running, which risks are acceptable and which interests take priority. This requires insight into the dependencies between IT and day-to-day operations.
The second condition concerns decisions outside office hours. When an attack happens at night or at the weekend, there is not always time to consult board members. Rijnland’s mandate therefore specifies when staff or external cybersecurity specialists may intervene on their own authority, and who has the final say if the parties involved disagree on the approach.
The third condition, the company says, is that external specialists must know the organisation. According to Orange Cyberdefense, an external partner can only intervene responsibly if it understands the role IT plays in business processes. Veiligheidsregio Utrecht therefore introduces external specialists to the work in the emergency control room and at the fire service. Dennis de Geus, CEO of Orange Cyberdefense Nederland, cites the tablets in fire engines as an example. As well as navigation, they are used to assess whether firefighters can safely enter a building, as they show what is inside and what risks are present. De Geus says that a partner who does not understand this cannot place its decision in the right context, even though it may be a matter of life and death.
The fourth condition is practising the decision itself. The company advises regularly rehearsing scenarios in which systems may need to be shut down. This involves both the technical response and the question of whether responsibilities are clear. One example is a situation in which a cybersecurity partner advises shutting down a system while the organisation is concerned about the consequences. According to Orange Cyberdefense, rehearsing such situations brings ambiguities to light before a real incident occurs.
A call to boards
Orange Cyberdefense sees Rijnland’s approach as an example for other organisations. Risks differ from sector to sector, but according to the company, the question of who may intervene in an escalating cyberattack applies everywhere. It is calling on board members to make the pull-the-plug mandate a permanent part of their cybersecurity and crisis management approach.
This article was originally published in Dutch on MSP Business. Read the original →
